First up is a Hoffner "Hybrid Warrior" The body is leather, the reinforced collar, sight strip running down the front edge and the sweat shield are Kydex The Idea is an excellent holster. The execution and materials are just average. The leather isn't the highest quality. The boning is superficial. The fit is fair. The price is a bit high. Second up is a Blue Line leather thumb break pancake. Purchased when there was nothing else available. Really not bad at all and worth the money (very reasonable pricing). Wait was a bit longer than expected but Blue line is a one man shop and he's a full time LEO as well as going to school to get a Masters.